Article
1 min

A Court Recognizes Unconscious Bias in Sex Discrimination Claim

A recent ruling of the Victorian court of Appeal in the case of Austin Health v Tsikos marks a significant advance in the appreciation of how unconscious…

Symmetra
Fair Talent Pathways
September 9, 2026

A recent ruling of the Victorian court of Appeal in the case of Austin Health v Tsikos marks a significant advance in the appreciation of how unconscious biases can serve to activate and embed discrimination in the workplace.

The complainant, Christina Tsikos had been employed as an orthotist/ prosthetist by Austin Health in 2009. The evidence established that men doing the same job were paid more. A number of men in various roles had negotiated salaries at above the statutory-agreement level. On six occasions over the years, Ms. Tsikos’ attempts to negotiate that her salary be increased above the minimum statutory level were simply rebuffed.

The case was decided under the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic). Relevantly the Act provides that:

In determining whether a person directly discriminates it is irrelevant (a) whether or not that person is aware of the discrimination or considers the treatment to be unfavourable.

The Court found that unconscious bias was a significant element in the unfavourable treatment which Ms Tsikos had received. The Court accepted that the bias had not simply originated in the decision-making process of one individual at a given point in time but had rather permeated the organisation and impugned its generalised methods of decision-making. On the facts of the case it observed ”the unfavourable treatment is an accumulation of acts and omissions by many individuals over a long period”.

This case signals a more nuanced treatment of discrimination complaints and grievances influenced now by a deeper understanding of the operations of unconscious biases. Employers will have to be more aware of the fact that unfavourable treatment amounting to discrimination can surface from systemic and cultural inequities. They need therefore to be addressed on a systemic basis.

Related capability
Fair Talent Pathways
Explore the practice →
scribble-teal ringhalftone-alt ringscribble-teal ring
Keep reading

Related insights

Is leadership still worth it? Findings from our 2026 roundtable series
Fair Talent Pathways
Gated
Report
.
read

Is leadership still worth it? Findings from our 2026 roundtable series

Download the Report
Rethinking Unconscious Bias: The Necessary Systemic Component
Fair Talent Pathways
Framework
.
8 min
read

Rethinking Unconscious Bias: The Necessary Systemic Component

Read more →
The Emerging AI Divide: When Unequal Enablement Creates Unequal Opportunity
Human-AI Teams & Future-ready Working
Article
.
6 min
read

The Emerging AI Divide: When Unequal Enablement Creates Unequal Opportunity

Read the insight
halftone-alt-fuchsia ring
From thinking to action

Could these ideas work in your organisation?

Let's discuss how the thinking explored here applies to your leadership, culture and talent priorities.

halftone-alt ringhalftone-teal-split ring